By
Aquaboy on Sunday, December 4th, 2011 |
1 Comment
Question by Sky: Which of my bettas would be best with my platy? please read?
I have SIX platy fry at 3 months old, and they are huge, and yes I asked this before but stupid answers came up. so let me clear some things…
I found a betta in a tank of TETRAS and he was fine. I bought him.
I got my other betta from the tank of GUPPIES and he has looooong flowy fins, and didn’t care for the guppies.
Another betta I got was in with gentle balloon mollies, and I got HIM.
My betta has been with DANIOS, BALLOON MOLLIES, GUPPIES, TETRAS, ETC. So do NOT tell me they kill everything because I know you are wrong, and you also won’t get the “best answer” since you never answered the damn question.
Okay, three bettas that may go in with my tetra.
youngest is 5 months, mellow (or stressed, he is new), never been in community tank
2.5 year old male is active, fast, but good with other fish aka has been in community tank
the female is skittish but gentle with other fish aka has been in community tank.
Which one sounds the best to be with the platy? REAL answers only please, and don’t write books on how to care for betta, molly, or platy. I have plants and crevices for the betta, and by plants I mean loads, because I did have danios with him before (although they attempted “schooled” with him…weird…)
So, which do you think is okay in the tank? Thanks for any real, good answers
oh, by the way, if no best answers occur I may note I have no room for another tank as I have three, so it is possible that one betta will have to be in a bowl if people say “don’t put him in the tank” and word of advice.. the bowl is small, and a heater is too big. I am in a basement, and winter is mighty cold… So… All of them needs to be in a tank.
omfg fishlover thank you for an actual answer… about time
Yeah I have no idea about the new male, because he is fairly new so I have no idea what he is like…
I have one smaller tank (forget to mention that one haha) plus the three tanks mentoned. So don’t worry they will be fine, but I only have those ones and I cannot put one in with the mollies as one of my mollies is a bit of a bully (although the others would be fine). The other tank holds 2 month old balloon molly fry, or fry that is too big to fit in a betta’s mouth. Complete with floating plants and hiding spots. Them, not too worried about.
Best answer:
Answer by FishLover24
I would go for the 2.5 year old male or the skittish female. The male will hold out for himself in the tank of platy but if your worried about volince the female would be better but she might be a bit nervous. I’d try the male first if he seems violent then swap him for the female. Don’t try the new male till you have tried him with less risky fish first.
What do you think? Answer below!